9+ Best Tomatoes To Grow For Salsa

Few pastimes are more rewarding than growing your own salsa garden. It is really fulfilling to be able to harvest the majority or even all of the ingredients for your salsa from your garden.

Tomatoes are a key ingredient in salsa, and any tomatoes you cultivate in your garden, even if you are a novice gardener, will taste one hundred times better than store-bought tomatoes.

9+ Best Tomatoes To Grow For Salsa

There are several tomato varieties that may be cultivated in a salsa garden, but paste tomatoes or Roma-type are the best for salsas.

Because these tomato types are less watery and meatier, the consistency of your salsa will always be ideal.

Traditional varieties like San Marzano and colorful variants such as Cream Sausage are among the nine best varieties of tomatoes to grow for salsa.

What Are Paste Tomatoes?

Paste tomatoes, sometimes known as Romas (Romas are a kind of paste tomato), are cultivated mainly for creating pastes, but they are also perfect for sauces, drying in the sun, and stuffing.

Some home gardeners cultivate several paste tomato plants, whereas others do not. Exists a distinction between tomato paste and fresh tomatoes?

Paste tomatoes are distinct from other tomato cultivars in that they typically contain less water and fewer seeds.

However, the majority of paste tomato types, particularly those descended from Italian paste tomato varieties, are visibly elongated.

Because they contain less water, their fresh flavor is more intense, and they are easier to reduce into a sauce or thick paste.

In the past, stores may have marketed paste tomatoes as Roma tomatoes. If you have never had them before, you may purchase them to compare their flavor and texture to those of regular tomatoes.

What Do You Use Paste Tomatoes For?

Due to their less succulent flesh, paste tomatoes are typically bred for use in tomato paste and sauces, as their name indicates.

Due to the high water content of other types of tomatoes, it is far simpler and quicker to convert paste tomatoes to concentrated paste by heating or dehydrating them.

For the same reason, sun-dried tomatoes are favored over the tomato paste.

For canning, gardeners pick paste tomatoes, whereas both paste and whole tomatoes are used to make a sauce out of season.

Stuffing is another underutilized use of tomato paste. Some kinds have larger seed cavities, making it simpler to extract and fill them.

The meat will not leak large quantities of juice and water into the stuffing when using paste tomatoes in this way. The biggest disadvantage is that their elongated design makes filling very difficult.

Certainly, tomato paste may be used in salads. Although not as juicy as other salad tomatoes or beefsteaks, they are nevertheless juicy and delicious.

I wouldn’t plant paste tomatoes expressly for salads or sandwiches, but they may be used if you already have some.

Both tomato paste and tomato sauce do not need to paste tomatoes.

In reality, the majority of American gardeners more than a century ago grew tomatoes labeled for preserving or fresh consumption, such as the Bonny Best tomato.

Theoretically, any tomato variety may be used to preserve sauce/paste. However, it will need a much longer time to achieve the desired level of regularity. This is the only disadvantage.

Things To Consider When Growing Paste Tomatoes

Paste tomatoes should be handled similarly to other varieties of tomatoes in your garden. The great majority of paste tomato varieties are, however, determinate.

Determinate tomatoes, also known as bush tomatoes, reach a certain height, produce the bulk of their flowers and fruit simultaneously, and then stop production.

In contrast, indeterminate tomatoes grow into massive vines that produce tomatoes continually throughout the season until they are killed by frost.

The benefits of growing determinate tomatoes include not having to prune them and being able to collect the bulk of their tomatoes in a short period.

They are also ideal for canning since you can harvest a huge supply of tomatoes at once, rather than fretting about what to do with only two ripe tomatoes.

If producing tomatoes for sauces, canning, sun-dried tomatoes, and stuffing is your primary goal, you should plant paste tomatoes in your garden.

If you wish to eat tomatoes fresh most of the time and just preserve the extra, you may choose more conventional varieties and follow the freezing instructions given above for sauce-making and canning.

However, you may still plant a few paste tomatoes in your garden and monitor their progress.

9 Best Tomatoes For Salsa

9 Best Tomatoes For Salsa

When growing tomatoes for salsa, it is impossible to go wrong with these tomatoes. There are several different types with exceptional taste.

Amish Paste

A huge, versatile, and tasty Amish heritage with a substantial production.

Amish Paste, an heirloom tomato preserved by Amish communities for decades, resembles a Roma tomato on steroids: its rich tomato flavor is concentrated in its meaty walls, and it weighs an average of 8 to 12 ounces, which is much bigger than the majority of Roma tomato kinds.

Even though the majority of Amish Paste tomatoes are plum-shaped, sometimes they develop into little oxhearts.

Amish Paste tomatoes are tasty enough for salads and slicing, but they truly come into their own in salsas, sauces, and pastes.

This kind of paste tomato is indeterminate and will produce fruit until the first frost. Extremely high-producing cultivar.

San Marzano

A renowned Italian heirloom tomato with a more flavorful and substantial flesh than normal Roma tomatoes.

San Marzano tomatoes are maybe the only tomatoes on our list with a cult following that goes beyond gardening.

These are the same San Marzano tomatoes that you may have seen in supermarkets for three to five times the price of regular canned tomatoes.

These tomatoes produce large plum-shaped fruits in clusters on vines with an undetermined life span.

San Marzano tomatoes are often skinnier than their Roma counterparts, but they compensate by having more flesh per fruit.

Superior-tasting San Marzano tomatoes are sweeter and less acidic than common Roma tomatoes. In addition, their flesh is denser and their seeds are fewer, making them great for sauces, sun-dried tomatoes, and salsa.

If you want to pack your salsa with tomatoes, the flavor of San Marzano tomatoes will stand out.


A prize-winning grape tomato that produces exceptionally flavorful, thick clusters of fruit.

Juliet tomatoes are enormous, brilliantly crimson grape tomatoes with an excessively elongated shape resembling small Romas.

Juliet was chosen as an All-America Selections winner in 1999 for its vigorous growth, exquisite flavor, and exceptional resistance to cracking.

In addition, they tend to mature early, sometimes in as little as 60 days, and generate heavy, consistent yields of fruit, easily generating over 100 tomatoes from two plants.

Juliet is thus a standard among both professional and amateur gardeners.

Juliet tomatoes are adaptable. You may use them in salsas and sauces, slice them for salads, sun-dry them into tomato-raisin umami bombs, or just eat them fresh from the garden.

Highly recommended for those who like cherry or grape tomatoes.

Banana Legs

Long, beautifully bright plums with sweet, fruity overtones that will enhance the flavor of any salsa.

Banana Legs get their name from their vivid yellow color and elongated, banana-like look.

This heritage tomato is often more sweet and fruity than savory and has a low acidity level, similar to many yellow and orange types.

Banana Legs tomatoes are determinate plants, meaning they do not grow very tall and produce the majority of their fruit at once, making them excellent for canning in volume.

Despite their determinism, they produce plenty of banana-shaped golden fruits.

These tomatoes are equally tasty in salads and salsas and may be used to add color and flavor to any dish.

Sunrise Sauce

Compact, disease-resistant tomato plants packed with excellent, sunrise-colored tomatoes.

If you want bright orange tomatoes and a touch more sweetness in your salsa, the Sunrise Sauce tomatoes are ideal.

Sunrise Sauce fruits have an exceptional, sweet flavor and low acidity, making them a fantastic addition to any salsa or sauce, or they may be used as the only tomato variety to create a unique orange salsa.

They are meaty and not too juicy, much like other plum/Roma varieties, while being shorter than typical Romas.

These tomatoes are determinate, grow on little plants that seldom reach 3 feet in height, and are resistant to verticillium wilt and fusarium wilt race 1 to a very high degree.

A salsa garden variety that is relatively low-maintenance, high-yielding, and container-friendly.

Cream Sausage

Long, creamy-white to pale-yellow tomatoes with moderate acidity and high sugar content.

The Cream Sausage tomato, also known as Banana Cream, is a prolific, determinate variety with distinctively colored fruit.

These sausage-shaped, elongated tomatoes range in color from almost white to pale yellow, making them suitable for light yellow sauces or for complementing a salsa when mixed with other varieties.

Even though this is a determinate bush variety, it will need staking or a tomato cage since it is such a strong producer, producing up to 60 pounds of tomatoes per plant under ideal conditions.

Aside from that, it is a little plant that may be grown in containers.

Purple Russian/Ukrainian Purple

Purple Russian/Ukrainian Purple

Black plum tomato bursting with a sweet and acidic flavor.

Purple Russian (also known as Ukrainian Purple) is an old heirloom tomato with sweet, acidic, and flavorful dark red flesh. It is also known as Ukrainian Purple.

Even after ripening, the shoulders (top section) of Purple Russian tomatoes are often green. The inside is a gorgeous hue of dark red.

As an indeterminate tomato, this variety will produce crack-resistant fruit throughout the whole growing season and requires a large amount of space and support.

Purple Russians are resistant to illness and productive. A reliable manufacturer in northern areas.

Dwarf Saucy Mary

A unique dwarf tomato that produces large, green, very flavorful fruits.

To make green salsa, unripe green tomatoes are unnecessary. The mature flesh of the Dwarf Saucy Mary tomato stays lime-green. In addition, its skin has yellow and green patterns.

As dwarf tomatoes, Dwarf Saucy Mary plants seldom grow taller than 2.5 feet, making them suitable for container planting. Nonetheless, they remain great manufacturers.

Excellent for green sauces, green salsas, and guacamole, as well as fresh consumption.

When these tomatoes are mature, they are tender to the touch and the yellow stripes on their skin grow more prominent.

Speckled Roman

A high-yielding paste cultivar with attractive orange and red stripes and an outstanding flavor.

The Speckled Roman is an additional variegated plum with red and orange stripes running lengthwise. Despite its magnificent appearance in the yard, its meat is a usual red/pink hue.

It is a stabilized cross between the exceptional paste tomato cultivars Banana Legs and Roman Candle.

Speckled Romans include few seeds, are moderately meaty with little gel, and have a balanced, classic tomato flavor.

Due to its flavor and texture characteristics as well as its high yields, it is a favorite among both professional and amateur cultivators. Highly recommended for tomato sauces and salsas.

Why Are Roma Tomatoes And Paste Good For Salsa?

Although any kind of tomato may be used to prepare salsa, paste or Roma tomatoes are optimal due to their lower water content, less gel, fewer seeds, and meatier flesh.

Using average tomatoes sometimes results in a watery salsa, especially after a few hours have elapsed and the flesh’s moisture has been absorbed.

Additionally, paste tomatoes are ideal for sauces and pastes because they need less cooking time to get the necessary consistency.

There is often not much of a taste difference between paste tomatoes and normal tomatoes, and regular tomatoes such as Abe Lincoln, Sungold cherry, and Cherokee Purple may contribute a great deal of flavor to salsas.

You may notice that some paste tomatoes have a stronger flavor, but this is mostly due to the lower water content, which dilutes the flavor.

If you aren’t growing paste/Roma tomatoes, you may still use your other tomatoes to create salsa, but you should first drain the extra liquid for the best consistency.

For raw, fresh salsa, dice your tomatoes and lightly salt them, then let them drain for a few hours on a paper towel or colander in the refrigerator.

For cooked salsa or salsa that will be preserved, you may use the same method or simmer the tomatoes until they achieve the required consistency prior to adding the other ingredients.

Final Thoughts

If you have an excess of ripe tomatoes, even if they did not make the list of the best tomatoes for salsa, use them in your salsa. Tomatoes grown on the vine are brimming with flavor, so they can’t go wrong.

Consider using a variety of tomato varieties in your salsa to enhance its flavor.

Many believe paste tomatoes to be the best tomatoes for homemade salsa because they contain few seeds, minimal liquid, and a meaty texture; however, if certain procedures are learned, any tomato may be used to make a superb salsa.

Since current tomatoes are less acidic than in the past, you will need to add lemon juice or vinegar to raise the acidity to preserve homemade salsa.

As salsa is often one of those recipes that people build (or remake) as they go, adding a little bit of this and a little bit of that, it is important to remember that if you want to scan your salsa, you must exactly follow the directions.

There is no other way to assess whether a recipe is safe for canning.

Salsa made from scratch may be frozen for future use. To freeze homemade salsa, only paste tomatoes should be used. When globe tomato-based salsas are frozen, they tend to become more watery.